The Department of Planning, Housing and Infrastructure’s
exhibition
notice for the Bells Mountain Battery Energy Storage System (SSD-83968208) names the applicant as
Edify Energy Pty Ltd and describes the project as the
Development of a 750 MW / 1,500 MWh battery energy storage system and associated infrastructure.
The site is 388 and 408 Sandy Creek Road, McCullys Gap. The application and environmental impact
statement are on exhibition from Tuesday 10 November until Tuesday 8 December 2026,
and the consent authority is the Minister for Planning and Public Spaces or the Independent Planning
Commission.
It is the third big battery proposed on this stretch of Sandy Creek Road. We reported the McCullys Gap battery next door when it was exhibited in September and October. For a Muswellbrook reader, the two useful questions about this one are what the community would be paid, and whether anyone has added up the traffic.
Bells Mountain battery at a glance
From the exhibition notice and the EIS (prepared for Edify, dated 28 August 2026).
- Size750 MW / 1,500 MWh, lithium iron phosphate; a two-hour battery
- Site15.62 ha at 388 and 408 Sandy Creek Road, about 6 km north-east of Muswellbrook, on land held under option agreements with two landowners
- ConnectionThe existing Transgrid Muswellbrook substation, east of the site
- BuildAbout 12 months from late 2027 or early 2028; 42 full-time-equivalent workers on average, 100 at peak
- LifeAbout 50 years
- ClearingUp to 2.01 ha of native woodland, 0.86 ha of it a nationally critically endangered community
- Traffic at peakUp to 192 vehicles a day, 108 of them heavy; about 50 trips in each peak hour
The community payment
The EIS says Edify would set up a community benefit fund through a planning agreement with
Muswellbrook Shire Council, plus a scheme it would run itself, and that the two together
contribute $150 per MWh per annum for the life of the Project.
A
On 1,500 MWh that is $225,000 a year, our arithmetic. The EIS adds that
Discussions between the Applicant and Muswellbrook Shire Council are still on-going at the time of EIS submission.
Exhibit A · from the source
The $150 is the state’s number. The department’s November 2024
Benefit-Sharing
Guideline sets total funding at
$150 per megawatt hour per annum for stand-alone battery energy storage systems
in rural zones, indexed to the consumer price index, and says the total
should not exceed the rates outlined above
(p. 24). The Bells Mountain site is zoned RU1 Primary Production, and the EIS says its offer is
in line with the threshold stipulated by the NSW DPHI ($150/MWh)
(p. 20). We found no mention of CPI or indexation anywhere in the EIS main volume.
Muswellbrook Shire Council wants more. Its staff
letter
on this project of 30 May 2025, written when it was still called Sandy Creek BESS, sets out what the
council resolved in February 2025 for battery projects:
A monetary contribution of $200/MWh consistent with the planning agreements with other BESS projects.
At $200, 1,500 MWh would be $300,000 a year. Next door, the
McCullys
Gap EIS, also on RU1 land, says
the project proposes community benefits at a rate of $200/MWh per annum
,
about $320,000 a year on its 1,600 MWh, and calls that In line with the Benefit-Sharing Guideline
(p. 133).
A year’s community payment from two neighbouring batteries
Dollars a year at full operation. Bars to scale; the full width is $350,000.
approximately $320,000 per annum (adjusted). The Bells Mountain figures are our arithmetic. McCullys Gap is the larger battery in energy (1,600 against 1,500 MWh) though about half the power (400 against 750 MW): the rate is per MWh, so storage, not power, sets the payment.
The council asked for more than money. Here is how the EIS answers the rest of the list.
What Muswellbrook asked of battery projects, against what the Bells Mountain EIS proposes
Council asks from its staff letter of 30 May 2025, items 2 and 15; EIS from the main volume. The tags are our reading.
-
Annual payment
Lower Council asked$200/MWh of installed capacity, every year of operation, indexed to CPI. EIS proposes$150/MWh a year for the life of the project, fund and Edify scheme combined; no indexation stated (pp. 19 to 20). -
How it is spent
Later Council asked10% to council specialist staff, 90% to the Muswellbrook Shire Community Benefit Fund. EIS proposesA four-part framework (neighbourhood, local community, council-managed and community-led), some run by Edify, some by the council through the planning agreement; no split stated (Table 2-5). -
Near neighbours
Partly Council askedNeighbourhood benefits as rate rebates for property owners in the direct vicinity. EIS proposesNeighbourhood benefits administered by Edify for those closest to the project; no rate rebate found. -
Apprentices and local spend
Not found Council askedAt least four shire residents as apprentices or trainees; a procurement plan with a 5% local target by value. EIS proposesNo apprentice number or local procurement target found in the main volume. -
Road wear
Later Council askedPavement damage on Sandy Creek Road calculated per project and part-funded through the planning agreement (resolution of 14 May 2024). EIS proposesRoad upgrades at the highway turn-off and site access before construction (Appendix N, Table 23); maintenance contributions not settled.
Three batteries, each assessed without the others
Sandy Creek Road leaves the New England Highway and crosses the rail line about 50 metres in. Bells Mountain’s
traffic
study, by Amber Organisation and dated 19 June 2026, lists the McCullys Gap battery
adjacent to the northeast
and the Gelston battery off Sandy Creek Road opposite the Project area
,
about 400 MW each. It then leaves both out of its numbers, along with the Muswellbrook pumped hydro
and thermal storage projects:
No traffic data is publicly available for these projects as the EISs have not yet been lodged and exhibited.
(p. 27). The projects it did count are the approved Muswellbrook battery and solar farm and the
highway bypass, at 51, 37 and 72 vehicles an hour.
That was true in June. The McCullys Gap EIS, dated August 2026, went on exhibition on 15 September, and its traffic
study had left Bells Mountain out for the same reason, saying projects at the EIS stage
do not have sufficient available inputs
(Technical Report 7, p. 49). Each study was written before the other was public, so neither
counts the other. Bells Mountain’s noise assessment has the same gap: it rates
the leftover impact at one receiver (R4) Marginal to Moderate
because
operational noise information for the nearby Gelston BESS, McCully's Gap BESS and Muswellbrook Pumped Hydro Energy Storage Project is not currently available
(EIS, p. 123).
Both studies modelled the same worst case at the highway turn-off: three trains an hour shutting the crossing for 3 minutes 43 seconds each. Both propose the same upgrade there, a channelised right-turn lane. They reach different answers on the morning queue on the highway’s southern approach.
Modelled morning queue on the highway, southern approach, while trains close the crossing
95th percentile queue in metres, as each study reports it. Bars to scale; the full width is 300 m. The two models use different counts and different sets of other projects, so they are not a like-for-like pair.
could be fully contained in the proposed right turning lane; McCullys Gap Technical Report 7, Table 5.4 (p. 41), which says
the queues are expected to extend back beyond the right-turn lane on the New England Highway.
The Bells Mountain study also records how much busier the turn-off already is than the state’s figures show: its April 2025 count found 988 vehicles in the morning peak hour and 1,094 in the evening, against 408 and 441 in the 2022 Transport for NSW data (p. 11).
How we read the documents
The NSW Planning Portal’s list of projects on exhibition was read on 11 November 2026. The Bells Mountain documents are listed under “Notice of Exhibition”, “EIS” and “Agency Advice” on its register page; the list loads only in a browser, and each document then downloads by plain request. We read the notice, the EIS main volume (prepared for Edify, dated 28 August 2026), Appendix N (traffic) and the council’s SEARs-stage letter, and searched the main volume for the council’s asks and for “CPI” and “index”. We did not read the other appendices. The McCullys Gap figures come from that project’s EIS and Technical Report 7, read for our October story. Arithmetic: 1,500 × $150 = $225,000; 1,500 × $200 = $300,000; the difference is $75,000; 1,500 ÷ 750 = 2 hours. The Bells Mountain EIS table of nearby projects gives McCullys Gap as 2 GWh; that project’s own documents say 1,600 MWh, which we use. We did not contact Edify, BW ESS, the council or the department.
Our read
This section is opinion, based on the facts and documents above.
The payment gap is a fight between the council and the state, and Bells Mountain is standing on the state’s side of it. Edify is offering exactly what the guideline asks, and the guideline says not to go higher. The council’s $200 is above that, and the McCullys Gap developer offered it anyway. Two batteries a paddock apart would then pay the same community at different rates. Over a 50-year life, $75,000 a year is real money for a shire fund. A submission that cares about the rate is better aimed at the department, which wrote the ceiling, than at the developer alone. Whether the $150 rises with prices also matters, and the EIS does not say.
The traffic gap is nobody’s fault, and that is the problem. Each study counted what was public on the day it was written, which is the rule. But the department now holds both EISs for batteries that share one turn-off and one level crossing, with Gelston still to come. The two studies give queues of 90 and 266 metres for the same turn-off under the same train assumption. A combined check of all three before any of them is approved is a fair thing for a submission to ask for.
Submissions
Submissions close on Tuesday 8 December 2026 and go through the project’s register page (“Make a submission”), where they are published. The notice says you can ask for your name to be withheld, and that a submission must declare reportable political donations from the last two years.
We will read the agency advice on the EIS, including Transport for NSW’s and the council’s, when it is posted to the register page after the exhibition, and report what it says about the payment rate and the turn-off.